Friday, March 5, 2010
Global Integrity Report: India scores a middling 70
An interesting report by Global Integrity (a not for profit organisation that generates information about governance and corruption trends around the world). In its score-card, India is at a moderate 70 scoring low on legislative and judicial accountability, civil service regulations, whistle blowing, rule of law and enforcement.
Monday, March 1, 2010
Why doesn't our government focus on good governance?
Good governance is the buzz word everywhere except among the political classes! Is it because they don't have their ear to the ground or they just don't care? I think its a mixture of the two. There are some politicians who understand that the voters are fed up of bad roads, lack of electricity, lack of quality schools, lack of law and order in many parts of the country, malnutrition and hunger and are making efforts to remedy the situation in their own small way. Nitish Kumar in Bihar is a good example. However, the majority, across the spectrum, are mired in old mind-sets and caste politics. How do we put the message across to these politicians that their game is up? If they want to be re-elected, they have to perform. For this, there needs to be consensus building across the political spectrum to bring about reforms in the structure of our civil service, the back bone that is supposed to deliver the goodies allocated to the people. There also needs to be reform in the way political parties function internally as well as in Parliament. For this, we need to amend the Anti-Defection law and bring in inner party democracy. Lastly, law and order has to be strengthened. We cannot have sundry goons hijacking an issue on the threat of violence without any repurcussions -- be it Valentine's Day celebration or women going to pubs or even larger issues such as Telangana.
Saturday, February 20, 2010
Aligarh Muslim University professor suspended for being gay
The news of the professor from Aligarh Muslim Univesity was caught on camera having consensual sex with a man is indicative of a far larger problem in our society than homophobia (which is not to say it is not a problem in itself). The way the professor was caught through hidden camera (whether set by students or some news company) shows a basic contempt for individual choice, privacy and more importantly the law of the land. This means any group of people can dictate the mores in society based on their lifestyle choices if they have the backing of people in positions of authorities. You may say that this has been a trend for a long time between goons and politicians. But such behaviour is not expected from an institution of learning.
THE GLOBAL “GO-TO THINK TANKS"
The University of Pennsylvania has published a global database of think tanks. You can access it here.
Thursday, February 11, 2010
Controversy over Bt Brinjal
Bt Brinjal is in the eye of the storm. While Jairam Ramesh has put a moratorium on its commercial cultivation, there is need to understand the issues at hand in more detail. Is the opposition to the plant valid? Is the Minister justified in ignoring recommendation from the Genetic Engineering Approval Council, which is a scientific body set up to govern genetically modified food? For more on the issue, please read the entry on the PRS Blog.
Focus on marriage, not so much on children
Do parents who focus too much on their children have less happy and demanding kids? Apparently so. For more information, please read http://bit.ly/a6Ggnd
Thursday, January 28, 2010
Ayan Hirsi Ali at Jaipur Lit Fest
Jaipur Lit Festival included a surprise visit by Ayan Hirsi Ali. Here's an account of what she said
Tuesday, January 19, 2010
A tale of female bonding
This article in Indian Express discusses the issue of female bonding beautifully exemplified by the real life case of Ruchika Girhotra (molested when 14 by SP Rathore a police officer) and Aradhana Prakash (the sole witness to the act).
We hear stories and get reams of paper about male bonding and male friendships but very little about female friendships. It is strange because in real life, female friendships seem to endure much more than male friendships which fizzle out quite easily.
We hear stories and get reams of paper about male bonding and male friendships but very little about female friendships. It is strange because in real life, female friendships seem to endure much more than male friendships which fizzle out quite easily.
Sunday, January 17, 2010
Underwear makes the moral police see red (or is it saffron?)
Apparently, women's lingerie is "obscene" in Madhya Pradesh!
Shopkeepers in Bhopal cannot display mannequins wearing women's underwear. Why, you may ask! The answer is because the Sanskriti Bachao Manch deems them to be obscene. You may then ask, who the f*** are they to decide on what is and is not obscene. There you have me flummoxed! I have absolutely no clue why they should get away with these decrees except that they seem to have the support of the state's BJP Chief Minister, Shivraj Singh Chouhan.
The side-effect of any kind of ban in India is the threat of violence and hooliganism. Most people comply with the dictats of such groups because they know the police would not come to their rescue when the hooligans attack. The police would not take any steps because these hooligans are backed by powerful politicians including the Chief Ministers.
In the midst of rising food prices, malnutrition, illiteracy and sundry other problems, why would politicians and their satellites think that anyone would care for such ridiculous moral policing? We need to seriously ponder over this question. Is there really a vote bank that gets all riled up about women's underwear? If so, who are these people? If there is no vote bank, then we need to ask what are the politicians getting out of such gestures? Is it a tactic to throw sand in the eyes of the voters to keep them occupied with inconsequential issues?
Unless, we look at these questions with a clear eye and expose this nexus, there is no hope for us.
Shopkeepers in Bhopal cannot display mannequins wearing women's underwear. Why, you may ask! The answer is because the Sanskriti Bachao Manch deems them to be obscene. You may then ask, who the f*** are they to decide on what is and is not obscene. There you have me flummoxed! I have absolutely no clue why they should get away with these decrees except that they seem to have the support of the state's BJP Chief Minister, Shivraj Singh Chouhan.
The side-effect of any kind of ban in India is the threat of violence and hooliganism. Most people comply with the dictats of such groups because they know the police would not come to their rescue when the hooligans attack. The police would not take any steps because these hooligans are backed by powerful politicians including the Chief Ministers.
In the midst of rising food prices, malnutrition, illiteracy and sundry other problems, why would politicians and their satellites think that anyone would care for such ridiculous moral policing? We need to seriously ponder over this question. Is there really a vote bank that gets all riled up about women's underwear? If so, who are these people? If there is no vote bank, then we need to ask what are the politicians getting out of such gestures? Is it a tactic to throw sand in the eyes of the voters to keep them occupied with inconsequential issues?
Unless, we look at these questions with a clear eye and expose this nexus, there is no hope for us.
Pakistan's school education in doldrums
An interesting article in the Washington Post caught my eye.
We have all heard about the faulty history taught in Pakistan's public schools. But the effects of such teaching is being felt now. This should make us re-think our history textbooks which mostly teach the Marxist interpretation of history.
We have all heard about the faulty history taught in Pakistan's public schools. But the effects of such teaching is being felt now. This should make us re-think our history textbooks which mostly teach the Marxist interpretation of history.
From From critical, very critical, very very critical, extremely critical to dead - Jyoti Basu RIP
Finally, the CPI(M) patriarch is dead at the age of 95!
It might be churlish to crticise him on the day of his death, but his horrendous legacy in West Bengal cannot (and should not) be brushed under the carpet just to preserve the niceties. I don't know what Marx originally had in mind when he propounded his theories of Communism, but his followers have in most part left a legacy of bloodshed, violence, mass poverty, and corruption. Basu was no different. From a fairly well to do state, he took Bengal into the depths of poverty and despair that it is in today. So, like Kanchan Gupta, I cannot mourn his passing.
It might be churlish to crticise him on the day of his death, but his horrendous legacy in West Bengal cannot (and should not) be brushed under the carpet just to preserve the niceties. I don't know what Marx originally had in mind when he propounded his theories of Communism, but his followers have in most part left a legacy of bloodshed, violence, mass poverty, and corruption. Basu was no different. From a fairly well to do state, he took Bengal into the depths of poverty and despair that it is in today. So, like Kanchan Gupta, I cannot mourn his passing.
Friday, June 12, 2009
Sri Lanka: An Eyeopener
We all have preconceived notions about various persons or places. To my mind, Sri Lanka was one of those places that Western tourists find fascinating for the cultural quaintness but otherwise like any other Indian town in the southern part of the country. It was vaguely on my to do list, mostly because a friend of mine was posted there but I had no sense of urgency about going there.
This May I was supposed to be going to Leh for a week (my room mate and I had been planning the trip since February) but the Gods had other ideas. At the last moment our trip got cancelled due to some unforeseen mishap in my room mate's office. Weirdly enough, around the same time, another friend's trip to Thailand got cancelled due to unforeseen circumstances. So there we were, two girls itching to get out of Delhi without any clue where to go.
After a series of discussions and hectic planning, we hit on Sri Lanka as a viable destination for a short trip within our budget and time constraints. My friend in Colombo was enormously helpful. She took care of hotel bookings.
We landed in Colombo at 2am. It was raining outside and we couldn't locate the driver who was supposed to pick us up and take us to the Taj Samudra. We located a post office and used the phone to call the driver (my friend had helpfully texted his cell number). Then followed a bizarre conversation with me trying desperately in English to explain to the guy (whose English was extremely limited) that we had arrived and were waiting for him. The driver: "You come at 2?" Me: "Yes, we are outside the airport"; Driver: "Outside? Me inside airport. You come at 2?" Me: We are standing at the Arrival." This went for a few minutes...finally my friend had a brainwave and said, "Mention that we'r waiting at the Post office." The moment I mentioned post office he brightened and said "I coming," and sure enough, the car and glided in 5 mins.
We were finally on our way to the hotel. Night time Sri Lanka looked quite quaint with a charming old world feel to it. Suddenly, we were flagged down by a couple of army guys with AK 47s slung across. Both our hearts started beating faster and our throats were dry as the driver buzzed down the window. Surprisingly enough, the army guy very politely wished the driver good morning and asked something in Sinhalese (presumambly about us). The driver said something back and I heard the phrase Indian High Commission!! I had no clue what was going on. The army guy then very politely asked me for my passport as well as Sarita. I was freaking out a bit because while I have an Indian passport, Sarita's is American. If the driver was trying to pass us off as Indian high Commission staff, it might be a bit difficult to explain how one of us had an American passport!! The check went off without a hitch and we breathed a sigh of relief! I asked the driver why he mentioned the High commission. He said otherwise they might want to check our bags. Then he launched into a mini history of LTTE and its attacks.
From the airport to the hotel, it was a 45 min ride. But we were stopped by the army some 10-12 times. Each time the same story was repeated, each time we were let go with a quick check of our passports. while it was very scary to have guys with AK 47s slung on their back stopping us very few minutes, they were extremely polite and courteous in their behaviour towards us and the driver. We were quite impressed.
This May I was supposed to be going to Leh for a week (my room mate and I had been planning the trip since February) but the Gods had other ideas. At the last moment our trip got cancelled due to some unforeseen mishap in my room mate's office. Weirdly enough, around the same time, another friend's trip to Thailand got cancelled due to unforeseen circumstances. So there we were, two girls itching to get out of Delhi without any clue where to go.
After a series of discussions and hectic planning, we hit on Sri Lanka as a viable destination for a short trip within our budget and time constraints. My friend in Colombo was enormously helpful. She took care of hotel bookings.
We landed in Colombo at 2am. It was raining outside and we couldn't locate the driver who was supposed to pick us up and take us to the Taj Samudra. We located a post office and used the phone to call the driver (my friend had helpfully texted his cell number). Then followed a bizarre conversation with me trying desperately in English to explain to the guy (whose English was extremely limited) that we had arrived and were waiting for him. The driver: "You come at 2?" Me: "Yes, we are outside the airport"; Driver: "Outside? Me inside airport. You come at 2?" Me: We are standing at the Arrival." This went for a few minutes...finally my friend had a brainwave and said, "Mention that we'r waiting at the Post office." The moment I mentioned post office he brightened and said "I coming," and sure enough, the car and glided in 5 mins.
We were finally on our way to the hotel. Night time Sri Lanka looked quite quaint with a charming old world feel to it. Suddenly, we were flagged down by a couple of army guys with AK 47s slung across. Both our hearts started beating faster and our throats were dry as the driver buzzed down the window. Surprisingly enough, the army guy very politely wished the driver good morning and asked something in Sinhalese (presumambly about us). The driver said something back and I heard the phrase Indian High Commission!! I had no clue what was going on. The army guy then very politely asked me for my passport as well as Sarita. I was freaking out a bit because while I have an Indian passport, Sarita's is American. If the driver was trying to pass us off as Indian high Commission staff, it might be a bit difficult to explain how one of us had an American passport!! The check went off without a hitch and we breathed a sigh of relief! I asked the driver why he mentioned the High commission. He said otherwise they might want to check our bags. Then he launched into a mini history of LTTE and its attacks.
From the airport to the hotel, it was a 45 min ride. But we were stopped by the army some 10-12 times. Each time the same story was repeated, each time we were let go with a quick check of our passports. while it was very scary to have guys with AK 47s slung on their back stopping us very few minutes, they were extremely polite and courteous in their behaviour towards us and the driver. We were quite impressed.
Thursday, May 7, 2009
I was forced to be a Pappu
Why was I forced to be a Pappu? Because inspite of trying thrice, I could not vote. Reason: my name was not on the electoral roll of three polling booths.
I have always been very proud of our democracy. It is actually one of the few things I admire about this country which is riddled with almost every possible social, economic and political evils. After today's experience, I am perilously close to giving into complete pessimism and cynicism.
I came home (Gurgaon) all set to vote yesterday. According to the RWA notice, our polling booth was supposed to be in F Block Community Centre, DLF City, Phase 1. We went there bright and early and was told to find our names on the electoral rolls. There were two booths, one set up by the BJP and one by the Congress. We started browsing through the electoral rolls (with five other people craning their necks trying to see if their names were in it too). Every page brought disappointment. Our names weren't there!! We asked the people at the booth how do we find out our polling booth. They were clueless...one guy tried to tell me it was the voter's responsibility to find this out!! No one even knew where the other polling booths were. Finally someone told us there was a polling booth in G-block also for Silver Oaks people. My father and I reached the place but again we were disappointed. the same story was repeated. No one knew where our names were, how we could find out which polling booth to go to, where the polling booths were located, etc. etc.
We came back home. I started searching on the internet. The Election Commission of India's website had the option of searching electoral rolls but it was not working. Then I tried calling the helplines on the Haryana Electoral Department (ceoharyana.nic.in). Someone picked up but instead of giving me any info just shouted at me that it was the wrong number and banged the phone. All the other numbers were either perpetually busy or just kept on ringing. The numbers are: 2224047; 2220860; 2220861. Finally, after searching on the net for hours, I figured our names might be in the Chakarpur Block A DLF Phase 1 polling booth. So at 3:30pm we trudged there in the heat but the same story was repeated. No one had any clue, our names were not on, etc etc. That's when we just gave up!! I have rarely been this disappointed in my country!!
I have always been very proud of our democracy. It is actually one of the few things I admire about this country which is riddled with almost every possible social, economic and political evils. After today's experience, I am perilously close to giving into complete pessimism and cynicism.
I came home (Gurgaon) all set to vote yesterday. According to the RWA notice, our polling booth was supposed to be in F Block Community Centre, DLF City, Phase 1. We went there bright and early and was told to find our names on the electoral rolls. There were two booths, one set up by the BJP and one by the Congress. We started browsing through the electoral rolls (with five other people craning their necks trying to see if their names were in it too). Every page brought disappointment. Our names weren't there!! We asked the people at the booth how do we find out our polling booth. They were clueless...one guy tried to tell me it was the voter's responsibility to find this out!! No one even knew where the other polling booths were. Finally someone told us there was a polling booth in G-block also for Silver Oaks people. My father and I reached the place but again we were disappointed. the same story was repeated. No one knew where our names were, how we could find out which polling booth to go to, where the polling booths were located, etc. etc.
We came back home. I started searching on the internet. The Election Commission of India's website had the option of searching electoral rolls but it was not working. Then I tried calling the helplines on the Haryana Electoral Department (ceoharyana.nic.in). Someone picked up but instead of giving me any info just shouted at me that it was the wrong number and banged the phone. All the other numbers were either perpetually busy or just kept on ringing. The numbers are: 2224047; 2220860; 2220861. Finally, after searching on the net for hours, I figured our names might be in the Chakarpur Block A DLF Phase 1 polling booth. So at 3:30pm we trudged there in the heat but the same story was repeated. No one had any clue, our names were not on, etc etc. That's when we just gave up!! I have rarely been this disappointed in my country!!
Wednesday, April 29, 2009
In praise of democracy
I recently read an article that said many Pakistanis were mad that their state was being called a failed state. The reporter interviewed some students who said their preferred form of protest was raising awareness through Facebook (a social networking site). The reason given was that they were women and it has become increasingly unsafe for women to participate in protests outside their homes.
Now, it seemed strange to me that these students did not realise there is a co-relation between their lack of safety and the failure of state. The very fact that the country is becoming more fundamentalist makes it more unstable and prone to failure. So a few people joining protest causes etc on Facebook is hardly going to make a dent in that country's path to destruction. The only thing it will do is mislead some people about the reality of Pakistan.
I have never understood how a country can be theocratic and claim to protect the rights of all its citizen equally. A theocracy is fundamentally unequal because it privileges one religion over all others. To top that, if religious laws govern the land, there can be no pretence of equality of any kind -- of the sexes, of religious minorities, of vulnerable sections. That is why the best form of government is a democracy with separation of church and the state. In a democracy there is space for dissent, unlike a theocracy.
Now, it seemed strange to me that these students did not realise there is a co-relation between their lack of safety and the failure of state. The very fact that the country is becoming more fundamentalist makes it more unstable and prone to failure. So a few people joining protest causes etc on Facebook is hardly going to make a dent in that country's path to destruction. The only thing it will do is mislead some people about the reality of Pakistan.
I have never understood how a country can be theocratic and claim to protect the rights of all its citizen equally. A theocracy is fundamentally unequal because it privileges one religion over all others. To top that, if religious laws govern the land, there can be no pretence of equality of any kind -- of the sexes, of religious minorities, of vulnerable sections. That is why the best form of government is a democracy with separation of church and the state. In a democracy there is space for dissent, unlike a theocracy.
Thursday, October 2, 2008
A Wednesday: Good movie but...
Harry Potter once stumbled across a mirror which reflected the deepest desires of the person looking into it. The images were so seductive that a person could spend the whole of his life just looking at it, so the wise Dumbledore warned Harry.
A Wednesday had a similar kind of effect on me. Rationally I know that vigilante justice is wrong. However, looking at the utter incapability of our police in nabbing terrorists, there is a small part of me that wants to cheer a person who would have the guts to do what Naseeruddin Shah does in the movie. A Wednesday is one of the best directed movies I have seen in a really long time. Neeraj Pandey's (the director)first attempt at directing makes me salivate for more goodies. Its terse, tight, and packs a punch. Of course, with actors such as Anupam Kher and Naseeruddin Shah playing the main roles its difficult to go wrong (although its been known to happen, remember Anupam Kher in some of the worst mainstream movies!)
Here, Anupam Kher as Inspector Prakash Rathod gives a fantastic performance. Cynical yet dedicated, he tries to negotiate with an anonymous caller who claims to have planted bombs in various places in Mumbai. A little into the movie, we realise that Naseeruddin Shah is the person who plants bombs. For the most part, he appears to be another of those deadly Islamic terrorists with an ordinary face who wants to wreak vengeance for his cause (whatever that might be). However, as the movie moves towards the climax, the plots twists into something else entirely. It turns out that Shah is not a terrorist but one who claims to be a representative of the Common Man a la R.K. Laxman. Tired of the incompetence of the police in ensuring safety for the common man, he takes it upon himself to destroy four dreaded terrorists. However, he knows the only way to ensure that they are killed is to blackmail the police into releasing the 4 terrorists and killing them himself.
The only slightly "filmy" part of the movie is where Shah launches into a diatribe against state incompetence and the vulnerability of the common man who has no religion, caste, creed or danger. Just ordinary citizens trying to go about their daily business.
What scares me is the topicality of the movie. The day that I watched the movie was a Sunday at PVR Saket. It was probably the first time that my friend and I managed to get tickets for the movie just 10 mins before the show. For that, we have the series of bomb blasts in Delhi to thank for. One could see the fear in people as they meekly submitted to thorough security checks and looked around suspiciously for any unclaimed packages lying around.
While no one disputes that the police are incompetent, they are also hampered by the fact that they get inadequate training, inadequate pay and manpower. Top it off with constant political interference and its a wonder that India as a country functions at all. It also does not help when every action of the police (even legitimate ones) is viewed through the prism of communalism. Instead of condemning the terrorists who kill, a number of members of the Muslim community and a number of activists claiming to be "secular" (without ever defining what exactly it means to them) or protectors of "human rights" (it begs the question, which humans, when they only seem to come out of the wood work after some terrorists have been nabbed), want to tarnish every action of the police. I think they don't realise that they are really not doing a service to the minority community. For good or bad, in a democracy, state is or should be the only agency that can use violence as a legitimate way of dealing with criminals. If they undermine the state, they are endangering all citizens of the country. No one is questioning the need for reforms in the state organs. That has been overdue for ages. But there is a difference between systematically denigrating the system of law and order in the country and agitating for reforms. Because at the end of the day, the best protection for any person can only come from the state, not from vigilantes of any type.
A Wednesday had a similar kind of effect on me. Rationally I know that vigilante justice is wrong. However, looking at the utter incapability of our police in nabbing terrorists, there is a small part of me that wants to cheer a person who would have the guts to do what Naseeruddin Shah does in the movie. A Wednesday is one of the best directed movies I have seen in a really long time. Neeraj Pandey's (the director)first attempt at directing makes me salivate for more goodies. Its terse, tight, and packs a punch. Of course, with actors such as Anupam Kher and Naseeruddin Shah playing the main roles its difficult to go wrong (although its been known to happen, remember Anupam Kher in some of the worst mainstream movies!)
Here, Anupam Kher as Inspector Prakash Rathod gives a fantastic performance. Cynical yet dedicated, he tries to negotiate with an anonymous caller who claims to have planted bombs in various places in Mumbai. A little into the movie, we realise that Naseeruddin Shah is the person who plants bombs. For the most part, he appears to be another of those deadly Islamic terrorists with an ordinary face who wants to wreak vengeance for his cause (whatever that might be). However, as the movie moves towards the climax, the plots twists into something else entirely. It turns out that Shah is not a terrorist but one who claims to be a representative of the Common Man a la R.K. Laxman. Tired of the incompetence of the police in ensuring safety for the common man, he takes it upon himself to destroy four dreaded terrorists. However, he knows the only way to ensure that they are killed is to blackmail the police into releasing the 4 terrorists and killing them himself.
The only slightly "filmy" part of the movie is where Shah launches into a diatribe against state incompetence and the vulnerability of the common man who has no religion, caste, creed or danger. Just ordinary citizens trying to go about their daily business.
What scares me is the topicality of the movie. The day that I watched the movie was a Sunday at PVR Saket. It was probably the first time that my friend and I managed to get tickets for the movie just 10 mins before the show. For that, we have the series of bomb blasts in Delhi to thank for. One could see the fear in people as they meekly submitted to thorough security checks and looked around suspiciously for any unclaimed packages lying around.
While no one disputes that the police are incompetent, they are also hampered by the fact that they get inadequate training, inadequate pay and manpower. Top it off with constant political interference and its a wonder that India as a country functions at all. It also does not help when every action of the police (even legitimate ones) is viewed through the prism of communalism. Instead of condemning the terrorists who kill, a number of members of the Muslim community and a number of activists claiming to be "secular" (without ever defining what exactly it means to them) or protectors of "human rights" (it begs the question, which humans, when they only seem to come out of the wood work after some terrorists have been nabbed), want to tarnish every action of the police. I think they don't realise that they are really not doing a service to the minority community. For good or bad, in a democracy, state is or should be the only agency that can use violence as a legitimate way of dealing with criminals. If they undermine the state, they are endangering all citizens of the country. No one is questioning the need for reforms in the state organs. That has been overdue for ages. But there is a difference between systematically denigrating the system of law and order in the country and agitating for reforms. Because at the end of the day, the best protection for any person can only come from the state, not from vigilantes of any type.
Sunday, August 31, 2008
Jaane tu...ya jaane na: Breezy and light
There are some movies that are deep, meaningful, serious and then there is Jaane tu...! This is a madcap story of two friends who gradually discover that they actually love each other. This theme of course has been done to death in many Hindi and English movies. However, Jaane tu's USP are its cute storyline and characters. Jai, played by amir Khan's nephew Imraan Khan and Aditi, played by Genelia D'souza are best friends who hang out with a bunch of oddballs from college. Jai is your quintessential non-violent type (his mom, played by Ratna Pathak Shah, insists that his dad was a strong beliver of non-violence) while Aditi is a hell raiser. Since both hang out together almost constantly, their parents assumes they are in love and broach the subject of marriage. The idea is instantly rejected by both who insist that they have no such romantic feelings for each other and embark on finding their respective life partners. While they do manage to fool themselves for a little while that they are actually in love with other people, they eventually realise that they love each other.
When putting down the story in black and white, it sounds really cliched and dull. However, the movie is anything but that. It not only explores friendships but also focusses on parental relations and even the equation between a brother and sister in a very believable way. I really liked Aditi's brother, Amit's character. He is an introverted artist who behaves obnoxiously with Aditi's friends, especially Jai, because he and Aditi were best friends before Jai came into her life. The cameos by Ratna Pathak Shah, Naseeruddin Shah (in the role of Jai's dead father) and Paresh Rawal are a treat to watch.
However, it does reinforce the stereotype that a girl and a boy cannot be best friends without being in love. Hindi movies have come a long way (or at least some) from the traditional and melodramatic plotlines to showcase believable characters, non-traditional parents and friendships. But exploring the equation of a girl and boy being best friends without any romance involved remains a taboo for all directors.
When putting down the story in black and white, it sounds really cliched and dull. However, the movie is anything but that. It not only explores friendships but also focusses on parental relations and even the equation between a brother and sister in a very believable way. I really liked Aditi's brother, Amit's character. He is an introverted artist who behaves obnoxiously with Aditi's friends, especially Jai, because he and Aditi were best friends before Jai came into her life. The cameos by Ratna Pathak Shah, Naseeruddin Shah (in the role of Jai's dead father) and Paresh Rawal are a treat to watch.
However, it does reinforce the stereotype that a girl and a boy cannot be best friends without being in love. Hindi movies have come a long way (or at least some) from the traditional and melodramatic plotlines to showcase believable characters, non-traditional parents and friendships. But exploring the equation of a girl and boy being best friends without any romance involved remains a taboo for all directors.
Saturday, March 1, 2008
The Indian Budget for Dummies
Fiscal deficit, capital expenditure, gross domestic product, wholesale price index, excise duty...if you are like me (i.e. stumped by economic jargon), its likely that the Finance Minister's annual Budget speech leaves you reeling. Not because the fiscal deficit is rising or the gross domestic product has failed to deliver, but because of the onslaught of economic terminology bombarded at you. And if you are sitting with a bunch of economists listening to the Budget (again like me), its almost guaranteed that you'd feel like the world's greatest dummy! While people around you are making seemingly brilliant wise cracks about the Budget, you are desperately trying to remember the definition of Gross Domestic Product learnt during school economics classes some 15 years back.
So here's the Budget highlights for dummies:
a) More salary (yay): Not because your boss suddenly thinks you are brilliant but underpaid and decides to hike your salary but because the Finance Minister thinks you should get more money (the reason might just be a tad more complicated than the sudden illumination about your brilliance). And if you are a woman or a senior citizen you get to take home even more money!! Muah to Chiddu-:P
b) Debt relief (balle balle for farmers): The FM decided that farmers are special. Now what does that mean in budgetary terms? It means that you get to take loans from banks and the government repays them for you! Of course the FM seems to have forgotten that most farmers in India don't actually take loans from banks because of all kinds of procedural hassles...they take loans from money lenders who charge them exorbitant rates of interest. The actual people who take loans from banks are not the ones committing suicide since they are the relatively well off farmers. While I'm no economist (understatement of the year), even I can see that there is a logical fallacy in this. The people who are happy (other than the farmers who never paid back their loans) are the banks because they get their money back in full. And the most unhappy among the farmers would be the ones who foolishly scrapped and scrimped to pay back their loans. This, I think, is a textbook case of populism.
c) National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (NREGS) gets universalised: The universalisation happened before. The Budget had to fund it. How did it do so? It went and stopped all other employment schemes and put in that money with a little extra into the kitty of NREGS. Now, I'm a little confused about the whole idea of employment generation through this scheme. While I am all for dignity of labour and right to employment, it seems a little self defeating to restrict the scheme's funding to unskilled labour. Essentially, what happens is there is money for people to dig up places but the moment a little more skilled work is required (which you would need if you are serious about building even the most rudimentary of things), the funding dries up (the Act stipulates the ratio of wage cost to material cost should be a minimum of 60:40. So proportion of funding for materials and skilled labour has to be less than cost of wage of unskilled labour!). Wow!! Even my non-economics oriented brain can see that this is not going to work. Also, given the level of corruption, these elaborate schemes are just a drain on tax payers money. Why doesn't the government use the money to provide better education and infrastructure so that the poor can acquire the skill to get employed and not remain at subsistence level??
This is all for now folks! Will write more later.
So here's the Budget highlights for dummies:
a) More salary (yay): Not because your boss suddenly thinks you are brilliant but underpaid and decides to hike your salary but because the Finance Minister thinks you should get more money (the reason might just be a tad more complicated than the sudden illumination about your brilliance). And if you are a woman or a senior citizen you get to take home even more money!! Muah to Chiddu-:P
b) Debt relief (balle balle for farmers): The FM decided that farmers are special. Now what does that mean in budgetary terms? It means that you get to take loans from banks and the government repays them for you! Of course the FM seems to have forgotten that most farmers in India don't actually take loans from banks because of all kinds of procedural hassles...they take loans from money lenders who charge them exorbitant rates of interest. The actual people who take loans from banks are not the ones committing suicide since they are the relatively well off farmers. While I'm no economist (understatement of the year), even I can see that there is a logical fallacy in this. The people who are happy (other than the farmers who never paid back their loans) are the banks because they get their money back in full. And the most unhappy among the farmers would be the ones who foolishly scrapped and scrimped to pay back their loans. This, I think, is a textbook case of populism.
c) National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (NREGS) gets universalised: The universalisation happened before. The Budget had to fund it. How did it do so? It went and stopped all other employment schemes and put in that money with a little extra into the kitty of NREGS. Now, I'm a little confused about the whole idea of employment generation through this scheme. While I am all for dignity of labour and right to employment, it seems a little self defeating to restrict the scheme's funding to unskilled labour. Essentially, what happens is there is money for people to dig up places but the moment a little more skilled work is required (which you would need if you are serious about building even the most rudimentary of things), the funding dries up (the Act stipulates the ratio of wage cost to material cost should be a minimum of 60:40. So proportion of funding for materials and skilled labour has to be less than cost of wage of unskilled labour!). Wow!! Even my non-economics oriented brain can see that this is not going to work. Also, given the level of corruption, these elaborate schemes are just a drain on tax payers money. Why doesn't the government use the money to provide better education and infrastructure so that the poor can acquire the skill to get employed and not remain at subsistence level??
This is all for now folks! Will write more later.
Friday, February 8, 2008
Taare Zameen Par: Finally, Bollywood shows a kid acting as a real kid
Yes folks! Taare Zameen Par is that rare Bollywood film where a kid acts like he is a kid and not like a mini version of a melodramatic adult. I can count on one finger how many Bollywood films show children as they really are (the only movies I remember are Masoom and Anjali, which was a remake of a south Indian film). Anyways, Darsheel as Ishaan is your normal 9 year old....messy, naughty, bratty but still retaining the innocence of childhood.
So the first half of the movie where Ishaan day dreams through class and expresses himself through paintings is a treat to watch. Also, the portrayal of the pressures that schools and parents put on children whether they are good or bad performers is very realistic. However, the movie goes a bit downhill in the second half where Ishaan is sent to a strict boarding school to be whipped into shape. There is no lack in Ishaan's acting...he is superb as the kid whose vitality has finally been subdued by the repeated insults and trauma that he suffers from all sides. The reason is Aamir Khan and his desire to give the movie a happy ending. It would have been enough if he had succeeded in identifying the problem and convincing the parents and teachers that the child did not lack brains, he had dyslexia, a learning disorder that could be successfully overcome.
However, the movie goes into overdrive, showing Ishaan making rapid progress and in the final instance winning the painting competition. This movie would have been Oscar material if it could have retained the level of reality it had in the first half.
So the first half of the movie where Ishaan day dreams through class and expresses himself through paintings is a treat to watch. Also, the portrayal of the pressures that schools and parents put on children whether they are good or bad performers is very realistic. However, the movie goes a bit downhill in the second half where Ishaan is sent to a strict boarding school to be whipped into shape. There is no lack in Ishaan's acting...he is superb as the kid whose vitality has finally been subdued by the repeated insults and trauma that he suffers from all sides. The reason is Aamir Khan and his desire to give the movie a happy ending. It would have been enough if he had succeeded in identifying the problem and convincing the parents and teachers that the child did not lack brains, he had dyslexia, a learning disorder that could be successfully overcome.
However, the movie goes into overdrive, showing Ishaan making rapid progress and in the final instance winning the painting competition. This movie would have been Oscar material if it could have retained the level of reality it had in the first half.
Sunday, December 16, 2007
Om Shanti Om - Truly a Masterpiece
Om Shanti Om (aka OSO) is a revealation. I expected a completely over-the-top albeit entertaining Bollywood Masala movie. It is all of that but much more too. I expected to be entertained but did not expect it to hold my interest as it did till the very end. I had truly underestimated the capability of Farah Khan (the director) and the magic of SRK (aka Shah Rukh Khan aka King Khan). The first half of the film has SRK playing a junior artiste and dreaming of becoming a star. But that is not his only dream. He also dreams of Shantipriya (Deepika Padukone), the superstar of that era(the 70s). Only SRK can portray the role of the intense lover with just that right dash of mushiness and intensity. I think the secret of SRK's success lies in the fact that his portrayal can send a chill (and thrill) down the spine of almost all women between the age of 15-50 and beyond. The film pokes good natured fun at the film industry, takes digs at the star power of surnames, parodies the mannerisms of stars -- all this without resorting to offensive jokes or vulgarity. The highlight of the first half though is SRK impersonating a South Indian movie star (presumably Rajnikant) to impress Shantipriya. Whether spouting gibberish or fighting a toy tiger or doing the sun glass flip of Rajnikant or saying "enna rascala Mind it" after every few minutes -- SRK is a riot!
As everyone knows by now, the story is of reincarnation ala Karz. So we have SRK and Deepika dying in the first half. The second half has SRK reincarnated as a super brat son of a famous star. The laughs continue with SRK playing roles such as Mohabbat Man and stars in "Apahij Pyar" as the lover who can't see, hear, speak, doesn't have hands or legs. But the second half is also when things start getting serious. SRK meets Mukesh Mehra, the psychopathic producer, superbly played by Arjun Rampal. He regains his past life memory and starts plotting revenge.
Farah has shown a deftness in directing that is commendable. There is overacting and melodrama where it works and exactly the opposite where it doesn't. So while Kiron Kher is the filmy mom, Rampal is chillingly understated. A word for the new actress, Deepika Padukone. She is excellent...beautiful, poised, vulnerable, and dignified. This is a definite must watch for all Bollywood lovers. It is not cerebral in any way but an excellent spoof on the industry.
As everyone knows by now, the story is of reincarnation ala Karz. So we have SRK and Deepika dying in the first half. The second half has SRK reincarnated as a super brat son of a famous star. The laughs continue with SRK playing roles such as Mohabbat Man and stars in "Apahij Pyar" as the lover who can't see, hear, speak, doesn't have hands or legs. But the second half is also when things start getting serious. SRK meets Mukesh Mehra, the psychopathic producer, superbly played by Arjun Rampal. He regains his past life memory and starts plotting revenge.
Farah has shown a deftness in directing that is commendable. There is overacting and melodrama where it works and exactly the opposite where it doesn't. So while Kiron Kher is the filmy mom, Rampal is chillingly understated. A word for the new actress, Deepika Padukone. She is excellent...beautiful, poised, vulnerable, and dignified. This is a definite must watch for all Bollywood lovers. It is not cerebral in any way but an excellent spoof on the industry.
Sunday, October 28, 2007
Lagaa Chunri Mein Daag - A Journey of a Woman
I have always loved Manna Dey's rendition of "Lagaa Chunri Mein Daag" in the movie, Dil hi to hai. The title track of Pradeep Sarkar's directorial venture, "Lagaa Chunri Mein Daag" has Shubha Mudgal crooning the song, interspersed with Mita Vashisht's poetry, "Manva mein mere toofan uthe madmast khadi hoon main". The choreography of the song is the high point of the movie.
How many times have we come across the same plot in Hindi movies: poor village girl coming to big city, not finding any work, getting hounded by big city wolves, resorting to prostitution? And Pradeep Sarkar chooses the same plotline albeit some modern touches. The usual kotha is replaced by fancy hotels and high rise buildings. Rani Mukherjee becomes a high class call girl, hob nobbing with the rich and the famous. Till Rani's transformation into a call girl the movie is quite watchable. But then it goes downhill. In his zeal to be politically correct, Sarkar has gone overboard trying to show the characters as modern and broadminded. Abhishek and Konkona as the love interest and the younger sister respectively have very little depth. The fun part of the movie is the chemistry between Kunal Kapoor and Konkona. The only believable character was Jaya Bacchan as Rani's mother.
Pradeep Sarkar had a brilliant cast but he chose to play it safe. This is film that could have been one of the landmarks of great cinema but ended up as a confused venture....neither hardhitting enough to appeal to the intelligentsia (or the arty type) nor commercial enough to appeal to the masses.
How many times have we come across the same plot in Hindi movies: poor village girl coming to big city, not finding any work, getting hounded by big city wolves, resorting to prostitution? And Pradeep Sarkar chooses the same plotline albeit some modern touches. The usual kotha is replaced by fancy hotels and high rise buildings. Rani Mukherjee becomes a high class call girl, hob nobbing with the rich and the famous. Till Rani's transformation into a call girl the movie is quite watchable. But then it goes downhill. In his zeal to be politically correct, Sarkar has gone overboard trying to show the characters as modern and broadminded. Abhishek and Konkona as the love interest and the younger sister respectively have very little depth. The fun part of the movie is the chemistry between Kunal Kapoor and Konkona. The only believable character was Jaya Bacchan as Rani's mother.
Pradeep Sarkar had a brilliant cast but he chose to play it safe. This is film that could have been one of the landmarks of great cinema but ended up as a confused venture....neither hardhitting enough to appeal to the intelligentsia (or the arty type) nor commercial enough to appeal to the masses.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)